I'd lean towards AS mostly because its just a fun game to play. GOT is a very good game, but is too deep and long playing for my taste. there's something to be said for keeping a game simple and fun (like monster bash). from a build quality stand point i feel AS is better also- the metal ramps, stock cliffy, better toys and LCD display. there is no question the art is far superior to GOT. Maybe i'd feel differently if I watched the series.