Quoted from kpg:

I almost bought a TWD Pro from someone on CraigsList before deciding to go with a Metallica Premium.
Why did I not buy the TWD Pro? The guy who owned it advised me against the purchase as the machine was boring and I wouldn't like it. Seriously, he talked me out of buying it. I still have no idea why he did this, but it didn't matter as 3 days later the ad was gone as someone bought it any way, likely against his own advice LOL.
Good luck on the trade, from what I've read many people buy the pin because of the show's hype - so now is a good time for the trade as I think it will slowly fall down the rankings once the popularity dies down.

Quoted from markmon:

Thanks for painting all owners of a game as a bunch of liars but it's just not true. I trashed my TWD the first time I owned it and sold it. The OP here is doing the same. The rule set in TWD is genius but the layout is frustrating and can be a deal breaker. The pops specifically are irritating. So yea, even though I own the game currently I can definitely see why someone wouldn't want it.

Quoted from Wamprat:

No such thing as a keeper imo. Every title that has come through our house has been sold at some stage, some I have really missed playing so I have bought them again.
It's all good, it's pinball, there is always another title to chase.