I have ordered plastic sets from both sources. Both are high quality reproductions. I prefer Pinball Rescues if I have a choice of the two vendors. I prefer the protective film the Aussies use as compared to the protective covering Shay uses (sometimes it is almost impossible to remove even with heat). Lee and Gordon keep their web sight up to date whereas Shay's not so much. I am still waiting over a year for a set of Frontiersman plastics I ordered from Shay. I have tried several times to get a update to no avail ( I'm pretty sure they are still out of stock). Lee and Gordon state that this is a hobby for them so they only ship once a week, but they stick to their word. Every time I have ordered from Shay it requires at least to followups before he ships my product. I am by no means trying to bash Shay. His product is top notch and I will continue dealing with him. He is a great asset to this hobby. All I'm trying to say is that if you are in a hurry for your platics I would buy from Pinball Rescue, but either way you can't go wrong.