Blackbeard - thought about this yet?........
have you actually scored more than 500,000 on the machine yet? (I don't know what a typical score on Gorgar is, but the factory high scores are usually high enough to make them a reach for a new player).
Your 500,000 is the factory default setting for high score. Your high score won't show up until you beat that.
Or, you could go into the adjustment menu and set the factory score to something low so you can actually beat it and see your high score flashed.
Or maybe I'm crazy and you routinely score a billion every time you play and the high scores just aren't saving. If that's the case, you've got some strange RAM problem.