Selling my LOTR is what brought me to Pinside!
Had LOTR for eight years and was done with it. I had one game last two hours and more than I could count last an hour or more......that got old. Sold it 5 years ago and still don't miss it.
I've learned that I generally prefer more difficult games....and by difficult I mean short ball times not getting to the ultimate wizard mode. I have Zero games over 15 minutes on IM and I LOVE IT!
Sell it....get something new and don't look back. Since selling my LOTR in 2012 I've sold 15 other games and don't regret any. There are a few I might buy back some day.....but probably not. To many other pins to try.