All a mater of perspective (your personal preferances) and condition of the games. I'd never trade my TAF for a AFM as I feel TAF is the superior game (my personal preferance).

I assume the prospective trade is nearby to you? If you have to do international shipping and what not I'd factor that hassle in to the decision making process for you (shipping games domestically alone sucks, couldn't imagine international).

This is a tough decision and ultimately one that you will need to decide on your own.

I would personally have a hard time trading two machines for one but condition is everything, and if the two machines you have are worth about the same as a decent AFM then I would consider it.

Keep in mind though that AFM is the rumored CGC next title which could have a negative effect on the current value of the Bally machine, just as MMR had on its original counterpart.

Save up some cash, sell CFTBL, keep TAF and add an AFM. TAF and AFM are both great games.

I have all 3 and if I had to sell Creech would be the last to go.

Such cool games. Hard to tell. 2 for 1 does sound kind of depressing for any situation though, no?

I think I would hold onto them, personally.

I would keep TAF and Creech, I like AFM but it's over-priced imo and I don't enjoy it as much as the other two games.

I say keep what you have and wait unless you can trade with some on local for a while ie loaner swap type deal. TAF is one that everybody wants so if you do sell it may have a harder time getting another one. I have played all 3 and would buy them if price was right but i not paying the current price even if i had the money. I personally think they are way high just because everybody wants one and someone will always pay more then the next clown.

Where is the option to forget about AFM because TAF is 3x's the game AFM ever will be?

Keep CFTBL, ditch TAF & save your $.

TAF + CFTBL > AFM.....I sold my AFM to get TFTC (plus pocket cash for something else in the future)...for me TFTC is keeping me more entertained than AFM did (which is still a great pin)...t

Love afm and its my favorite pin. Sold cftbl with no regrets and like tz better than addams.
Lots of addams families made compared bto original afm so if i cld get a good deal on one i wld do it. Games get stale after a while so why not change thing's up?

Of course, all great games. I've had all three and sold the TAF recently to help fund another pin purchase. Still have the AFM and Creech. Had TAF for 10 years or so and put a lot of games on it. Decided it was time to change it up a bit. Can't go wrong with any of them.

TAF is king of the hill in my book!