I traded my JM for a BSD and don't regret it at all.
I'm also a horror fan and had a strange fascination with the movie, video game, and pinball as a kid.
but I would love to own a JM again and put it next to BSD.
I still prefer BSD over JM, even if the code is more shallow. BSD is a quick game, reminds me of a an EM in a way, and the pursuit for the triple stack is still enjoyable after owning and playing the game a lot before that.
JM is Great but BSD will complement any collection well. its shallow and will kick your ass but when everything clicks there's nothing like it.
I have thought getting rid of it from time to time, but I know I would only want to get it again.
Sorry for my long post and bias to drac and I haven't said anything about it that hasn't been said before but If they are the only 2 games at a bar the BSD will get more quarters out of me than JM.