Add one to the collection. I don't know how you held on 2.5 years before coming to the conclusion that you are addicted. It took me only 8 months from the time I bought my first game before I decided to add a 2nd. The 3rd one followed within 3 month of that one. Next thing I knew, I had 5.

So even if you try to stick to one, you will always want something different. It is time to add to that collection, not subtract. Play ball !!

If you get TWD get a premium. Love mine. It has become my favorite stern.

Prices on used TWD Premiums are super reasonable now. Pro is great too. That, and a SW pro will keep you happy for a LONG time.

Dialed In. Amazing pin, Only negative is the price. In the same price range I’d also consider MMr and AFMr

If you are planning to build your collection quickly beyond 3 pins, I see no good reason to go beyond a pro for starters. It's not like the pinball collection judges show up and ding you for style points for getting a pro. Now, if you are only going to add another pin every 2-3 yrs, then it makes sense to step up to the premium level (If the game warrants it...)

OK, now that I have said that, I would recommend going for 1 of either TWD prem - OR - MET pro or Prem AND Then 1 of either AFM or MM.

SO, a 2 game collection, huh.... Any of the suggestions would work. You know, for long term play-ability it is hard to beat AFM or MM. Then throw in TWD, Met, SW or any of the recent Sterns and you can't go wrong. People love TWD for the rule set, but I am not in love with the theme, as I am not into Zombie culture. The other thing you can do is just get whatever 2 are easily accessible and plan to swap out wholesale every 2 yrs... TWD & SW would be awesome.

I'm enjoying the hell out of BM66 and would recommend it. If the price and availability are scaring you off, see if you can hold off until the code hits 1.0; nobody wants to let go of them until they've played it with the completed code. I assume once that happens, a bunch of BM66 Premiums will come up for around the same price as a TWD Premium.

Go on pinballmap.com
Lots of games on location in Madison.

I found Addams Family’s layout constricting and would hesitate putting TWD next to it. There both great but I find both frustrating and two frustrating games as the only games yeah no.
Your other choices might fit better.

Keep TAF and add a second. There are many affordable choices. It’s called pinball “collecting”, not “swapping”

+1, I like the premium better

I would go with MMr or AFMr. Both games are home runs and family friendly. The humor sets them apart from all the rest.

^ what he said

Go hard or go home. TNA or BSD

TWD Prem gets my vote.

Don't hesitate to get a SW if you like the theme, as it doesn't have any more negativity than others early in their life cycle. It is a really good machine. Heck, TWD was panned for months, but is now considered a great machine by most.

I own both and had a TAF. Either would compliment TAF's play well in a 2 game collection.

I really enjoy my B66LE !! The play is simple and hard as hell!:)So,I would go for a B66!! If you do ,make sure it has all the current code! Lots of great mods now available as well! Yelobirds new atomic pile is a must!!Have fun,play ball!!!

I love my bm66 too...and you can mod the heck out of it! The clips from the show just make you want to watch it all over again...it’s extremely well integrated. I’d highly recommend it...and as you said, the code has come a long way. Great game!

Keep the TAF. Add a Williams IJ, if you want to go cheaper (but still a blast) — The Shadow, or if you want to go cheaper still (but still a blast) — a T2. My first pin was my TAF about 3 years ago. I’ll never get rid of it. T2 was my second pin because I didn’t have $5K+ for an IJ... TS will likely be next.

Get the Data East Star Wars.

Node Board issues seem to be a common issue with the Star Wars I've seen.