Quoted from RVH:When I used to drink scotch it was anything from Balvenie.
I've had a lot of them and there all great.
I'm with RVH! I have about 30 different bottles in my liquor cabinet, but basically anything Balvenie (sherry cask is my favorite) is my go to.
You seem to like peaty scotch though. I'd recommend trying either Port Charlotte or Ardbeg. Both are heavily peated, and quite smooth.