Decided it's time for an update on my favorite modes and then my opinion on ranking their difficulty.
Villain modes ranked by preference:
1. Miner 49er
2. Black Knight
3. Charlie the Robot
4. Captain Cutler
5. Creeper
6. Witch and the Zombie
7. Space Kook (I've never gotten to its alt mode. Only really tried once. That might affect my preference once I get to it)
*Worth noting that I think all 7 villain modes are pretty great
Villain modes ranked by difficulty (easiest first)
1. Charlie the Robot
2. Miner 49er
3. Creeper
4. Witch and Zombie
5. Space Kook
6. Black Knight
7. Captain Cutler (got REALLY close to beating this mode for the first time just a little bit ago. Can't believe I've still never finished it)
Character modes by preference:
1. Shaggy
2. Velma
3. Fred
4. Daphne (this mode being ranked #4 is really impressive because I love her mode)
5. Scooby (honestly, this is the only mode in the whole game that I actually don't care for. It's just too convoluted for me. Too much use of the action button. But hey, that means I really dig 11 of the 12 modes. That's pretty darn good)
Character modes by difficulty (easiest first; assume playing as matching character):
1. Daphne (her character ability usually makes her mode a cinch)
2. Shaggy (hardest part is not being greedy)
3. Velma (haven't played it enough to really understand Velma's ability on this one. Also still not sure how to tell from the iron maidens if the glasses are on the main or upper playfield)
4. Fred (really like the mode, but no matter how simple of a plan I create, I always seem to choke on the second half lol)
5. Scooby (way too hard)