You guys should just take it to PM or drop it at this point. You might as well argue politics or religion for all the good it'll do you because you'll never see eye to eye on this. Opinions are like assholes - everybody's got one, and there are plenty of both on Pinside.
My beef with people is when they say "Rush sucks" or anything sucks for that matter. It's pretty ignorant IMO. You don't like it...great! That doesn't mean it sucks, and trying to make that argument makes you sound like you're in middle school.