Quoted from Calgedy:My logic in this example is not flawed....... I did not say this is the rule......Rush is my all-time favorite band.....Dave era Halen is #2. Everyone is influenced by someone and in some cases yes, the influencer gets surpassed. Not in this scenario. I agree Eddie wipes the floor with Eric Clapton, but others would disagree.
Right - what you said exactly was "Les, who is a GREAT bassist, couldn't hold Geddy's jock strap. Did you know that Les' #1 influence is Rush and Geddy Lee?"
Translated, that sounds like 8th grade algebra - "Since Les idolizes Geddy, he couldn't possibly be better than him..........."
So yes, your logic IS flawed. The pupil can indeed become the master. Whether that's the case here or not is irrelevant, it's the thought process I commented on.
We now return you to your regularly scheduled programming.