Quoted from Haymaker:I think its the shape of the hole itself that is the main cause of the deformation. They didn't router the edge nicely, its just a step cut, so the protector has "air" behind it, which makes it weak. I'm not convinced a different protector is going to work much better, but maybe.
I feel like it is a very thin protector, and the front hole is much smaller/narrower than a usual scoop hole. The side scoop doesn't deform as fast. But the ball I think is hitting the protector, then the two side tabs start bending in and stopping the ball. I don't think it is "1" thing but like ^, it is all the things together that are causing this.