I heard that Stern is going to release a Tron VE to make up for this and it'll be available this year with no wait time after purchase.
I heard that Stern is going to release a Tron VE to make up for this and it'll be available this year with no wait time after purchase.
Quoted from Bangback:The top of the protector looks like a Cliffy, but the inside of the hole looks like a Mantis. Best of both worlds?
You would have to post a pic of it, but if it has thin metal covering the perimeter of the hole, you can expect that to get peened into the filleted shape of the hole edge.
Quoted from Bangback:Hopefully someone comes up with a good solution.
I have a cliffy on order... pondered getting a mantis as well. See if one allows shots better. I get some decent rejects.
Quoted from Hayfarmer:Let's just say my name starts out miff
Let's be thankful it doesn't start out Clantis! We could call it Dunder Mifflen, but that's already taken for sure.
Quoted from Bangback:The top of the protector looks like a Cliffy, but the inside of the hole looks like a Mantis. Best of both worlds?
I'm not sure I know what you mean.. the protector wraps around the edge in spots (as most cliffy's do for mounting)... I don't recall any metal ring around the PF cutout.
Quoted from flynnibus:I'm not sure I know what you mean.. the protector wraps around the edge in spots (as most cliffy's do for mounting)... I don't recall any metal ring around the PF cutout.
This is from my MBrLE. There’s an outer cliffy style protector and also an inner mantis style protector. But yeah I’m beginning to see some pounding on the outer part.
D441862E-A5FF-4BB3-8167-64EEEA08CE40 (resized).jpegQuoted from Bangback:This is from my MBrLE. There’s an outer cliffy style protector and also an inner mantis style protector. But yeah I’m beginning to see some pounding on the outer part
You're right, it does look like a Mantis-style protector in there. Like I said before, if you have a properly set Mantis, there is no need for a Cliffy-style on the edge, so says my MB. I guess it might make you feel better with the additional protection, but it will also detract from the beauty as it inevitably becomes dented/dimpled over time.
Quoted from sudsy7:You're right, it does look like a Mantis-style protector in there. Like I said before, if you have a properly set Mantis, there is no need for a Cliffy-style on the edge, so says my MB. I guess it might make you feel better with the additional protection, but it will also detract from the beauty as it inevitably becomes dented/dimpled over time.
I agree with you as I have other games with just a Mantis only protector and they have been fine. This is just how my game came from Chicago Gaming.
Cliffy is testing! https://www.passionforpinball.com/wip.htm
"Rush scoops, vuk, target bank and ejects in PLAY TEST now. Email me at [email protected] to get in the wait list. Play testing as of 3/15/22!"
Quoted from Animal:Cliffy is testing! https://www.passionforpinball.com/wip.htm
"Rush scoops, vuk, target bank and ejects in PLAY TEST now. Email me at [email protected] to get in the wait list. Play testing as of 3/15/22!"
Thanks for the heads up!!! Got on the list.
Quoted from ian866:No comment !?
[quoted image]
Here’s my opinion on this.
What I think they should do from the start, is take about a 1/3 of that blue rubber off
So it’s sitting back more and sturdier but I’m wondering if they are trying to use that rubber to prevent corners from bending up?
Is that what is going on?
Quoted from pinmister:Not a fan of Stern's V3 scoop fix. #1 it is fugly! #2 it blocks the scoop shot and makes the shot super tight. The upper cliffy is still going to get slaaaaaamed! If only Stern would have used Mantis protectors from day one? Wonder how many replacement pf's are being sent out for this faux pau. If I had a RUSH with a mangled pf I would not be a happy camper.
-Also the guys in the RUSH thread-please stop stating that mylar is a good fix and works well-total band-aid solution and has me shaking my head.
[quoted image]
That looks like something out of a horror thread...
I choose to believe its a stopgap they're sending out to buy time until they come up with a solution that actually holds up. I don't want to be convinced otherwise.
Im waiting for my Rush game to arrive and then I plan on measuring up the hole. ive done a decent amount of sourcing of deep drawn stainless parts over the years. I believe a proper deep drawn stainless part with appropriate radiuses on both the "brim" of the hat as well as having a full perimeter drawn section into the playfield hole may prevent a lot of the warping. The current designs are just a series of ears dropping into the play field. as a result these don't add to the stiffness of the plate section.
Quoted from BradAlbright:I had no idea about any of this, but happened to play it on location today and was so dumbfounded by what I saw that I took a video (stills here). Pretty wild.
[quoted image][quoted image]
Ya - my pro is getting like this. Ball gets stuck.
Not sure what to do - fix seems slow to come from Stern.
Quoted from kool1:Ya - my pro is getting like this. Ball gets stuck.
Not sure what to do - fix seems slow to come from Stern.
I'd get on the list for a Cliffy. He is very reasonable with his prices and you will most likely get it before Stern has a solution.
Quoted from Monk:I'd get on the list for a Cliffy. He is very reasonable with his prices and you will most likely get it before Stern has a solution.
Yeah but Cliffy is in the process of testing right now and he posted that he's not happy with how his front scoop protector is holding up.
Quoted from meSz:he's not happy with how his front scoop protector is holding up.
I like how honest Cliffy is and that he stated the fact on the product's information page. I knew this debacle was not going to be an easy fix. Both scoops get slaaaaamed and Mantis may be our only hope.
Need a Miffy like yesterday, at least I am not hot to trot for RUSH anymore and am looking forward to see what Gomez does with the 007 theme. Hoping they will do extensive beta testing this time around.
-Hey Miffy your so fine you blow my mind-Hey Miffy! Hey Miffy!
For those of you who are not aware, a new scoop protector is available from Aniraf and is called the TPU or Ninjacamp. It is made from polyurethane and preliminary testing is very promising. It's in production (with many sales already) and so there will be plenty of real world test data soon.
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/the-official-rush-owners-club-1/page/60#post-6833224
Quoted from sudsy7:a new scoop protector
It does look interesting but it also looks like it does not lay completely flat? Not sure how thin you can get with plastic without breaking? Does the height affect the ball travel at all? How many plays do they think they will hold up for?
Who would have ever thought-a plastic miffy?
Quoted from pinmister:It does look interesting but it also looks like it does not lay completely flat? Not sure how thin you can get with plastic without breaking? Does the height affect the ball travel at all? How many plays do they think they will hold up for?
Who would have ever thought-a plastic miffy?
Don’t remember which thread I saw the dude posting in, but it is that 3d printed plastic stuff. He has videos of him hitting it with a hammer and crumpling it up in his hand, etc. Its not gonna break. Not in love with the way it looks, but it may be at the very least a decent temp fix.
Edit: just noticed the guy above mentioned both the thread and link to it.
Quoted from pinmister:It does look interesting but it also looks like it does not lay completely flat? Not sure how thin you can get with plastic without breaking? Does the height affect the ball travel at all? How many plays do they think they will hold up for?
Who would have ever thought-a plastic miffy?
I asked him about it laying flat and he says it absolutely lays flat - the picture is deceiving. All your questions will be answered by fellow pinsiders soon as these are shipping right now.
It's not a Miffy - there's nothing about this that resembles a Mantis. It is a plastic Cliffy though.
Looks great to me, mine should be here in a day or two, but I'm on cliffy list as well , to be safe.
Quoted from Hayfarmer:mine should be here in a day or two
Nice-give us the review and I really hope they work.
If all else fails there is always Duck Tape-it fixes everything (;
RUSH scoop debacle (resized).jpgWhite duck tape (resized).jpegQuoted from sudsy7:Mantis is available now. I like the Ninja better.
[quoted image]
Now we’re talking!
Does this mantis version fit the pro model cause the pro model doesn’t have that large metal plate that the LE/prem seem to have?
Quoted from sudsy7:Mantis is available now. I like the Ninja better.
[quoted image]
Where’s the protection for the top ?
Quoted from J-drum11:Where’s the protection for the top ?
Mantis doesn’t protect the top explicitly. The internal protection prevents top damage.
Quoted from J-drum11:Where’s the protection for the top ?
Quoted from Guinnesstime:Mantis doesn’t protect the top explicitly. The internal protection prevents top damage.
Yes, the thick, hard liner provides a top "rail" that that ball makes contact with instead of the wooden edge of the scoop hole. As long as the ball cannot hit the edge of the hole, no damage will occur.
pasted_image (resized).pngQuoted from J-drum11:Where’s the protection for the top ?
Mantis mentions in his PS thread he's working on the upper scoop protector.
https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/new-mantis-parts-available-1#post-6853828
Quoted from Chrizg:Does this mantis version fit the pro model cause the pro model doesn’t have that large metal plate that the LE/prem seem to have?
That's a good question. ???
Quoted from sudsy7:Yes, the thick, hard liner provides a top "rail" that that ball makes contact with instead of the wooden edge of the scoop hole. As long as the ball cannot hit the edge of the hole, no damage will occur.[quoted image]
My MET Mantis doesn’t come up that far, but you can see that it’s done it’s job over the past 9 years (ignore the wax residue inside the scoop). It comes right up to where the bevel starts.
Quoted from swampfire:My MET Mantis doesn’t come up that far, but you can see that it’s done it’s job over the past 9 years (ignore the wax residue inside the scoop). It comes right up to where the bevel starts.
I have a MET, too. Mine has a Cliffy. However, mine also has a playfield protector on it just like yours. I think the playfield protector guards the edge of the hole. If the ball can't hit the edge, it can't damage it. I do see a minor chip on the right edge of yours. A lot of times the hole will get wallered out when the ball is ejected from the scoop, and the Mantis is a great barrier to that kind of beating. I've seen some MB scoops you could almost put a billiard ball in.
For God's sake, wipe that gob of wax off there. What are you - an animal?
Quoted from sudsy7:I have a MET, too. Mine has a Cliffy. However, mine also has a playfield protector on it just like yours. I think the playfield protector guards the edge of the hole. If the ball can't hit the edge, it can't damage it.
For God's sake, wipe that gob of wax off there.
will do
Believe it or not, there’s no protector on that playfield - I just clean and wax it religiously. The shiny part is the factory mylar, which oddly is missing on Rush.
I do have a playfield protector for my Rush, the first time I’ve ever done it. I’m liking it so far.
Quoted from Chrizg:Does this mantis version fit the pro model cause the pro model doesn’t have that large metal plate that the LE/prem seem to have?
Quoted from sudsy7:That's a good question. ???
I had access to a Pro in addition to my LE during the prototyping of the protector. The Mech attachments and posts are identical. The only reason I can think of for Stern to use the plate on the Premium/LE was to help the ball transistions between scoops as they behave different on the two versions. That being said I have not physically tried Mantis' prototype to the Pro.
Here are some pics comparing the two, with the later being from a Pro:
C21EE044-0474-4F49-9D86-0F4F98AE5BCF.jpegC46418AB-8942-437F-BBF7-79C5F1440F4F.jpeg
Quoted from swampfire:Believe it or not, there’s no protector on that playfield - I just clean and wax it religiously.
I don't see any dimples and it looks like there are some flecks of chaff or whatnot that might be trapped under a plastic sheet is why I thought yours had a protector. Must be the camera angle. Anyway, I don't recall ever seeing a Mantis that low in the pocket on any machine, and it looks like Kerry is making sure that the Rush protector is set near (but below) the playfield plane.
I put the ninja scoop protector on today. It kind of pulled up where the posts tightened down, but otherwise seems very flat. Played the monthly tourney afterward and no one even noticed or said anything. I had a little indent in the wood on the right of the front scoop, not sure this will protect super hard hit balls? but i'm just glad to have something on the wood for a route game.
Thank you for sharing, I have not seen that video. Im curious if everyone is having good luck with the ninja scoop protectors? I am so desperate for just something that works. Stern is not ready to ship these kits yet.
Quoted from Fordiesel69:How is the plastic / rubber ninja working so far?
Stern protector junk after 50 plays. Ninjacamp protector perfect after 200. You can decide.
Quoted from kool1:Another happy Ninjacamp customer
Thanks guys.. This product is super impressive. My game finally plays like it should have out of the box. [quoted image]
I agree!!
I just received the updated version from stern. It will stay in a box.
What I’m wondering is….. will stern be using the updated version for all front scoops on future machines? I sure hope not
Quoted from J-drum11:I agree!!
I just received the updated version from stern. It will stay in a box.
What I’m wondering is….. will stern be using the updated version for all front scoops on future machines? I sure hope not
Quoted from sepins:For a guy like Me, watching Borg do it makes Me wonder if I'll ever get it back together correctly?
Don't put that one in, buy the ninja. 30 minute install, very easy. Looks 100x better too.
Quoted from sepins:For a guy like Me, watching Borg do it makes Me wonder if I'll ever get it back together correctly?
I'm not super handy and I was able to do it.
Just be careful not to lose any pieces and go slow.
Quoted from kool1:I'm not super handy and I was able to do it.
Just be careful not to lose any pieces and go slow.
Thanks will go with Ninja. Is there an install video for them?
Wanna join the discussion? Please sign in to reply to this topic.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run without any 3rd-party banners or ads, thanks to the support from our visitors? Please consider a donation to Pinside and get anext to your username to show for it! Or better yet, subscribe to Pinside+!
This page was printed from https://pinside.com/pinball/forum/topic/rush-aftermarket-metal-scoop-protectors-/page/3?hl=largemouthass and we tried optimising it for printing. Some page elements may have been deliberately hidden.
Scan the QR code on the left to jump to the URL this document was printed from.