I felt terribly ripped off by fact that TFA is essentially a remake of episode 4. That was pitiful. Felt lazy. Loved Harrison Ford and some of the other characters, however.
Rogue one was much better in my mind. Yes we know how the story ends. Yes the main characters had to die. However, the action was incredible, scenes beautiful and they re-discovered how to properly add comedy. Loved the tie-ins to episodes 3 and 4 and the characters they brought in from those movies.