Loved both movies, but slightly loved force awakens a bit more for the memorable characters and high points even though the plot is familiar. That moment where Rey force grabs the lightsaber from the snow gave me goosebumps!
Rogue one's third act is incredible though. The only issues were the soundtrack was pretty subpar... Force awakens is far superior there. Also it would have benefited from an opening crawl to explain where we are in the timeline.
Both movies were a lot of fun.. Excited for the new direction of star wars post prequels...