Quoted from jrivelli:Thanks for the tips there. I tumbled my stuff looking like that in coarse walnut with flitz overnight and was sorta shiny, but that stuff was still there mostly. Ill try what you said!
Also, can you tumble a final tumble with maybe fine walnut and flitz for a shinier polish?
I think you need to tumble longer and make sure the media is really moving around. If there is too much stuff in the tumbler it will take longer. I usually leave mine at least 24 hours sometimes 48 hours.
You can switch to the crushed corncob media (pet store) after you have run it for 48 hours and then run another 24 to 48.