I have had a similar issue on Gottliebs where it is the connector from the start button to the MPU that is not making good contact and then the start button does not work. I reseated that one and cleaned it up and it stopped the issue. I am not sure if this is it as I am unsure what the rest of the symptoms are.
The lack of free play on these games means double check that you have credits and everything mbaumle said!