I don't think you can go wrong. I am actually picking up a FT tomorrow, 2nd time I have owned one, excited about having it again. I have owned RFM as well. Both have a lot of fun factor and smile factor. Both have some of the same issues about not having much of an ultimate game...on RFM when you finish all 9 things, well you start over. Fish Tales, you get the Monster Fish...well, you go after another Monster Fish. So not the deepest of games either way. But that's some of the reason they have both stayed "reasonably priced" in this ever-increasingly priced pinball market. Both pretty family friendly, that's one reason FT sells easily. If it was me...well I would do the trade for something new, but that's just me. Good luck on your decision.