I've used Wolfpac displays in the past (their DIY kits) and have always been pretty happy with them. Can't speak to the other two choices though.

Pinscore is the most expensive option.

https://www.marcospecialties.com/pinball-parts/PS-11610

They always seem to be in stock at Marco, and in the dozen or so machines I've used them in I've never had further display problems.

I like the brightness adjustment pot. Rottendog and Wolffpac don't have this, they 'match the original display', which, if it works would be fine.

Wolffpac:

https://www.wolffpactech.com/product-page/williams-system-11b-d-11610-display

Rottendog:

https://www.pinballlife.com/mm5/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Product_Code=RD-DIS200

just put a set of Wolfpac in a game and oh so pretty !

Just be aware wolfpac doesn't come assembled. You have to solder the thing together.

Me, I want one already assembled.

If you can do some fairly basic soldering and have a half way decent quality soldering iron you can assemble Wolffpac displays. Finer tip is helpful for the ribbon headers but not necessary.

I just built green Wolffpac displays for my Grand Lizard (Sys 11) and my Space Station already had X-Pins. I can't tell the difference between the two and the Wolffpac was $154.95 to my door. X-Pins would have been $250+Shipping (Although they are already assembled).

I have a Black Knight where one plasma display digit is bad... i'll be putting Wolffpac displays in it as well, both of those kits will cost me a few dollars more than 1 x-pin display.

It's the option I would go for if you can assemble them yourself. Good quality product and looks excellent. I also got them in 2 days as they shipped from Delaware and I'm in Maryland. Anecdotally folks on pinside have mention Wolffpac support is very good.

Not trying to push my own products, but FYI: Absolute Pinball in Canada sells Wolffpac displays pre-assembled.

I'm late to this and as it happens I bought an Xpin main and remote for police force last week, super happy...However, big fans of Absolute pinball and that's really why I'm replying. I have bought a few things, the exchange rate is righteous right now and owner is responsive. If they have what you need, I wouldn't hesitate.

Oh, I meant to say my Xpin main and remote together as a package was $239 shipped. They have free shipping. The Wolffpac stuff looks good, and if it's similar, pre-assembled, I would consider it for next time, especially from Absolute. Good info to have.

And Gddammit if I would just read, you are already in the great white canuckistani north, so just ignore me and talk to Absolute. LOL