Quoted from Gexchange:4:03 — “It’s worth noting the Spike system is quite sensitive. If you were to replace one of the few removable LEDs with a traditional light bulb it will cause the Spike system to shut down or reset at random”.
Response:The Spike system is very robust and has passed rigorous laboratory testing that subjected it to shock, vibration, extremes in temperature, electrical shocks and radiation events way beyond what it sees in real world
With all due respect to George Gomez one of my favorite designers and talented people.
George LOL What laboratory was that may I ask? The Spike system has not held up in 4 NYC "REAL World Bars"
Quoted from Gexchange:3:34 — "Serviceability with Spike is not enhanced, in fact quite the opposite it true”.
Response: All new technology requires some acclimation period amongst service users. The Spike systems currently use menus that are directly based on the SAM system. A more updated diagnostic system, which takes advantage of the user interface available thru the LCD screen and built in smart diagnostics is currently in development. There are also numerous programs in development to train and educate the technical support community, operators and customers on troubleshooting techniques specific to the new system.
Yes the Spike system has diagnostics and a Sam Based menu system how does that help when it leads you to a failed Node board and
you are still stuck not being able to repair it unless you happen to have an expensive replacement node board on hand?
How many hours of operation would it take just to recoup the expense of the Node board?
This does not solve the serviceability issue.
Maybe node boards could be made socketed and with through hole components?
Maybe Node boards could be discounted by half to Operators with some form of proof that the particular machine is on location.
Maybe failed node boards could be replaced free of charge to Operators so that they could recoup the lost downtime revenue?
Or, which is really stretching it, Node boards could be sold for around $20
Im not an operator but as a Tech that independently works for operators I understand the situation fairly well.
I understand Stern too in that hey are trying to cut costs in order to make money as well but in this particular situation it may come back to haunt them.
“Replacing them is an expensive, time-consuming nightmare” (referencing the SMT LEDs)
Response:Again, this is common technology; SMT parts are currently used in consumer, commercial and industrial products worldwide.They do require specific techniques, training and tools but years ago when pinball went to solid state, that technology seemed equally daunting at first. There are numerous YouTube video’s on SMT repair tutorials.
As for this tech being used by Commercial and Industrial products yes true but at higher Spec levels according to intended use.
Its obvious from what is happening in the feild that the specs for the Spike system were not high enough for the intended environment and use.
Hmmm maybe that is part of the answer have the Spike boards meet Mil,FAA and Nasa Specs.