Which fingers do you use to play pinball? I'm right handed and I realized for some reason I always use my right middle finger and left index. I've played pinball this way for as long as I can remember and have no idea why. In fact I can't really play well with my right index, feels as awkward as trying to write with my non-dominant (left) hand. Just wondering how common or rare it is not to use both index fingers. I'm guessing 99.999% of people use both index fingers.