The early SS games are the pinnacle of pinball IMO. Gameplay, theme, artwork, sounds. They really are the total package. You're really splitting hairs when deciding between Stern, Bally & Williams titles from that era (and even the criminally underrated Gottliebs for that matter). My favorites that I've been lucky enough to play:
BALLY: Centaur, Fathom, Mystic, Flash Gordon, Embryon, Nitro Ground Shaker, Harlem Globetrotters, Skateball, Viking
STERN: Quicksilver, Nine Ball, Star Gazer, Catacomb, Cheetah, Dragonfist, Big Game, Ali
WILLIAMS: Barracora, Cosmic Gunfight, Warlok, Defender, Solar Fire, Time Fantasy
GOTTLIEB: Alien Star, Countdown, Punk, Eclipse, Striker, Black Hole, Devils Dare
Good luck finding some of these, let alone finding them available for purchase
In my general opinion, here's how I summarize them:
BALLY: Incredible artwork
STERN: Incredible gameplay
WILLIAMS: Incredible sounds
GOTTLIEB: Incredible parts
They may come & go through your collection since there are so many incredible titles across all the manufactures, but the Sterns never leave. They're just too good IMO.