Best - Tron
Worst - Who Dunnit
Best: AFM (I get my ACDC BiB this weekend, so this may change soon)
Worst: basically every Gottlieb/Premier game. There are a couple of games that are just decent, and the rest are TERRIBLE.
Also, I thought it was interesting that the OP listed ToM as the best and WoF as the worst. I'm not saying it is the greatest game on earth, but I enjoy WoF a lot more than ToM. ToM was the only WPC game I have ever had that I wanted to get rid of within the first week.
Rarest game played/owned:
Mystery Castle, which is amazingly fun for a scary themed game
Tough call, but I'd say right now my fave is Safe Cracker. It would have been amazing if Bally would have continued making token pins.
All pinballs are awesome, but I guess the worst playfield and creative executions I've come across would be the 2015 Stern Wrestlemania or Mustang. Just not for me. Too bright, and not very fun. Yet, I'd still play them
rarest played : BLY EM Star Ship (1)
rarest owned : BLY EM Fore (80)
Best : WMS EM Teachers Pet
Worst : BLY EM Circus/Big Show
Ah, well I guess when I was responding to "rarest" I meant "cause I haven't played it". God bless places like The Pinball Hall of Fame, ReplayFX, Arcade Expo and The Pinball Wizard in NH for giving people a chance to check out such rare games!
Rarest: Gottlieb's "Critical Mass" --only 1 "prototype" in existence
Best: It's a toss up. My favorite game is whirlwind, but it's not necessarily "the best" game.
Worst: William's "Jubilee"
Let me throw out something here. The OLDEST pinball I've played: 1933 Rockola World fair Jigsaw.
Great to see you're enjoying Pinside! Did you know Pinside is able to run thanks to donations from our visitors? Please donate to Pinside, support the site and get anext to your username to show for it! Donate to Pinside