It’s hard to rank your own games, so many ways to rank them. Do you rank them by what they mean to you? By your personal taste? Do you try and be objective in some way and not let your personal bias as to a pet theme get in the way? Do you rate them by your keepers or by the funnest games?

For example, three games I know I will never sell are Doctor Who, Varkon, and Safe Cracker, but they are three of my least played games and I would not rate any of them higher than Tron...but I’d sell Tron way before I sold any of those three.

Ranking that way favors the newest games in ones collection. Right now I love TBK and R&M and feel they are the funnest, but they are also my two newest games. I think you have to have a game for a year to take out the recency bias.

A game I always return to is Star Trek. I agree with you about X-Men, it is tragically under rated and one of the top Stern machines ever. I may try and do a ranking later.

Another issue to consider is fun alone vs fun with friends. A game like TNA is incredible with a group of friends over, but Star Trek or LOTRs will simply sit unplayed when friends are over due to ball times and people getting bored watching and not playing.

This is a great thread by the way!

Alright, I realized my collection was not up to do date thanks to this thread, so I updated it: Rick & Morty and Shrek now appear.

Okay, I rated based on pure simple fun I have with the games as of today...this is not reflective of how I think these games rank historically or their likely longevity in my collection:

1) Rick & Morty
2) The Black Knight
3) Twilight Zone
4) Star Trek Premium
5) Batman 66
6) The Addams Family
7) TNA
8) Bram Stoker’s Dracula
9) Elvira House of Horrors
10) Catacomb
11) Tron
12) Quicksilver
13) Wizard of Oz
14) Metallica
15) Doctor Who
16) Iron Man
17) Medusa
18) Dialed In
19) Safe Cracker
20) Seawitch
21) Solar Ride

Not rated at all yet: Shrek (just bought it yesterday!!!).

This is truly the best way to break it down, I might do some re-ranking into categories.

Another fun thread the OP may want to create that is similar to this thread, but different enough to warrant its own thread, is rate games you used to own but no longer own (exclude games you bought back and have currently, I would not be able to rate Tron of Iron Man, for example).

This category had my cracking up...I rate Varkon in that category too. LOL