In my rankings I made tiers. The games in those tiers could be swapped around. So TOTAN ranked 4th could be 2nd some days. I made my wife rank them in order of ones she's most to least excited to play. There's some recency bias. We JUST got Count-Down, for example, and we've owned or had access to The Walking Dead for many years.

Me
1 TBL
---- TIER BREAK ----
2 Harlem Globetrotters
3 Road Show (w/ Soren Mod & Personalized Music)
4 TOTAN
--- TIER BREAK ----
5 The Getaway
6 Black Knight
7 Count-Down
8 Who Dunnit!?
9 Paragon
---- TIER BREAK ----
10 The Walking Dead
11 Star Trek Pro
12 Alien Poker

Wife
1 Harlem Globetrotters
2 Count-Down
3 The Walking Dead
4 TOTAN
5 Who Dunnit!?
6 Road Show
7 TBL
8 Paragon
9 Alien Poker
10 Star Trek Pro
11 The Getaway
12 Black Knight

==============

GRAND TOTAL:
1 Harlem Globetrotters (21-23 points)

---- TIER BREAK ----
2 TOTAN (18-20)
3 TBL (18)
4(tie) Road Show (16-18)
4(tie) Count-Down (15-19)

---- TIER BREAK ----
6 Who Dunnit!? (12-16)
7 TWD (11-13)
8 Paragon (9-13)

---- TIER BREAK ----
9 The Getaway (6-10)

---- TIER BREAK ----
10 Black Knight (5-9)
11 Alien Poker (5-7)
12 Star Trek Pro (4-6)

==============================

Harlem is pretty amazing. We love that game. I didn't realize how much we actually liked TOTAN and here I was considering selling it. I may wait on that. Count-Down is still new so that'll fall in the rankings.