Impossible task but here's how I'd categorize my pins at the moment

I play the most now....

BM66LE
IMDNLE
ALIENLE

Best and most played pin ever.......

TWDLE

Pins that 99% will never leave......

BM66LE
ALIENLE
WH20
WOZECLE

Low cost fun factor pins.........

INDY500
WPT
NBAFB

The Rest of my pins.......

GBLE
ASLE
AFMrLE

Happy with my lineup right now!

Pins that came and went.....

LOTRLE
ACDCpremium
SM twice

This is tough!
13. IJ4 awesome Multiball start not much more but great for non pinheads
12. WOZ good looking game but just couldn’t get into it. Kept it because my dad and I bought it together
11. Ghostbusters looks pretty but code is just not that great.
10. ACDC great game that I never could get into. I love the train topper
9. Spider-Man awesome game but bought NIB so I have played it a lot

Now it starts to get tough
8. AFM super fun but just not as deep as the others
7. Iron Maiden will be higher but only have about 20 games on it
6. LOTR tough but something has to be out of the top 5

The top 5 are all awesome I love my games
5. TWD amazing game
4 Tron LE
3. Met
2. Kiss (this is where I lose credibility but it is my guilty pleasure)
1. STLE flowiest game and just plain fun. It is the game that just always call me back.

Dead Pool LE arrives tomorrow so we will see where it fits on the list.

Top to bottom
TZ
IJ
SW
TWD
IM
DW
WW
TH
GOT
TSPP
LOTR
TS
STNG
CFTBL
AFM
FT
MM
FG
ES
FH
WW
I500
BR

I put a picture for the first two ore you dont know what they are.
#1,Mc
#2,SDSO
#3,BSD
#4,wms FT

IMG_20171110_203937 (resized).jpg

1. TWD LE
2. Tron LE
3. T.Z.
4. M.B.
5. I.J.
6. CFTBL
7. IMDN LE
8. D.I. CE
9. AC/DC LE
10. G.B. LE
11. WH20
12. WOZ RR
13. AFM LE
14. BM66 LE
15. Alien LE
16. TOTAN

Pins that will never leave.
I.J. HEP
WH20 HEP
TOTAN HEP
TWD LE
Tron LE
Alien LE
BM66 LE

I didn’t know there were so many aliens out there. Is it a good game?

Nope..... It's like choosing a favorite kid!

1) Really, really Fun.
2) Frustratingly Fun.
3) Ain't Going anywhere.
4) thru 10) challenging.
11) Just like wood standing in a closet.

It changes over time but right now I would have to go:

1. Alien
2. IMVE
3. IJ
4. STTNG

Unfortunately I can't do this. My rankings change monthly. It would be stupid because right now, I'm addicted to Mustang Pro. So I'd rank it #1, and nobody would ever respect me in the morning.

That's one thing that happens in a good sized collection. You can't play them all all the time. So you zero in for a while. Mustang will cool off for me, and Tron or something will take its place for a few weeks. And by the time I get back to mustang in 6 months, it will feel brand new to me again. So eventually every game I own becomes number one for a while. And if it can't do that for me, that's when I sell it.

Yeah Brett has killer taste. Pleased to see my CFTBL so high up there

It would be ranked higher, once my wife stops playing it, and lets me have some time on it.
It’s now her favorite pin.

The theme and sound are incredible.

Thanks Patrick

Dems fight'n words.......

John

1)Afm
2)Bsd
3)Twd
4)Cftbl
5)FT
6)Bk2k
7)BoP

Nobody knows for sure, but more than likely less than 200 between the SE and LE were built.

Great pin. They nailed the theme, and code is really good. It’s unfortunate that they went under, and very few get to own.

We both have a restored WH20 Brett and gotta say that it is one gorgeous pin in "better than new" condition

Not to mention a fun pin to play. Color DMD coming for that one

When I saw how gorgeous yours is, I new one day I’d get one.
It’s a hard pin to find in great condition, unless it’s been restored.

Good move on getting the colored DMD.

This^^^^ ^^^^...
I have my top 1 or 2 then the rest are always like number 3 on any given day. I rarely sell anymore cuz I enjoy them all. I do have 1 permanently dtuck at the bottom though.

Whew......this type of thread has come up in several different iterations...I just can't favor any of mine, as they all have a solid place in my lineup....

The only thing I can say w confidence - there is my AlienLE, then there are the rest......

1. MET pro
2. TWD prem
3. BSD
4. ST prem
5. IMVE

1) TZ
2) MET pro
3) Shadow
4) Congo

#1 Swords of Fury

Depends on the day, but for me it's:

1. AFMr LE
2a. Wizard of Oz Ruby Red
2b. Dialed In LE

That’s my top 3 also.

MET Pre
Woz
AC/DC Pre
ST Pre
TAF
TSPP
TZ
LOTR
Vegas

I’m only ranking those that I have set up:
—Top—
BSD
Metallica
Judge Dredd
Getaway
Transformers Pro
Grand Lizard
Nine Ball
Fathom
Hoops
Sharkey’s Shootout
Torpedo Alley
Defender
Little Joe
Mr/MsPacman
Alien Star
Elektra
Argosy

—Bottom—

I love all my games but here goes:

TWD LE
TAF
DI LE
MET Pro
TSPP
IM
RS

I’ll just use the ones in my main game room. As others have stated it varies day to day.
#1 SS
#2 Met Pro
#3 LOTR
#4 TAF
#5 Stargate
#6 Funhouse
#7 Space Shuttle
#8 Cyclone
#9 Pinbot
#10 Bad Cats
#11 Freddy.

With a current lineup of two pins I’ve checked the number of plays and both are equal!

So it’s equal 1st for AFMRLE & TWD Pro

PS: PinBot went to make room for the AFMRLE.

Current list based on what I’m playing the most.

DILE
TWD Prem
SW Prem
MET Prem

1) GOTLE
2) X-MEN LE MAGNETO (even though it kicks my arse most days)
3) AVENGERS LE HULK
4) IMVE
5) RBION
6) SWING ALONG

I've had the occasion to ponder going from 30 machines to 9. I suppose these 9 would have to be my top rated games, so I can start there.

Whirlwind
White Water
TSPP
Creature
Cirqus Voltaire
Fireball
Godzilla
Black Hole
Judge Dredd

Worst game is that bacardi game they made in the UK.

Everything else is somewhere in between....

1. Ghostbusters Pro
2. Ripley's Believe it or Not
3. Jurassic Park
4. WWF Royal Rumble
5. Space Shuttle
6. Back to the Future

All keepers for me. Took me a long time to perfect my collection. Would still like a Centaur and TNA

1. MET 8.680
2. DI 8.656
3. IMDN 8.595
4. NGG 8.576
5. TNA 8.512
6. MM 7.984
7. Congo 7.528
8. TOM 7.520
9. BSD 7.220
10. Slugfest 7.094

As most say...this is today’s ranking:

The Shadow
Dialed In CE
Iron Maiden LE
White Water (HEP 2017)
Metallica Premium
Star Trek LE
Theatre of Magic (restoration)
LOTR LE
TSPP
Fish Tales (restoration)
Attack from Mars
Total Nuclear Annihilation
Corvette

tspp
Funhouse
tz
Taf

1. AFM
2. TZ
3. TAF
4. CFTBL
5. Indy 500
6. CV
7. T2
8. AC/DC

This was tougher than I thought. It’s hard to choose between a bunch of games you like. The EMs fell to the bottom, but I still think they’re great.

1. TWD LE
2. SW Premium
3. Getaway
4. Flight 2000
5. Fun Park
6. Jet Spin
7. WPT (only had it for a day so I’m not sure where it falls. I’m guessing between F2k and Fun Park)

Currently I play #5 the most

TWDLE
IMDN Premium
Tron LE
AC/DC Premium
AFMRLE
Metallica Premium
MM
TZ
IJ
Dialed In LE
LOTR
STLE
WH20
IM
CFTBL
TS
TAF
Congo

Top to bottom

JP
WoF
RG
BTTF
Strange Science
T2

Pretty happy with the present lineup and can’t see moving anything for a while. But guess the bottom 4 would be the ones to go first.

1. Tron
2. Iron Maiden
3. Monster Bash
4. WOZ
5. TWD
6. Batman 66
7. TNA
8. AC/DC
9. GOT
10. Metallica
11. El Dorado
12. TOM

I like these lists, I can sometimes look peoples ratings but they are not always complete.

Tied for 1st: My games that aren't GB
Definitely last: GB

From first to last

ACDC
Flash Gordon
Embryon
Metallica
Deadpool
Star Wars
CFTBL
TS
Centigrade 37
MM
EBD
TNA
IMDN
SS
AFM
RZ
AS

1. BK2K (I can’t explain my love for this pin)
2. JM (Power Down never disappoints)
3. 8B (my first pin)

I love seeing TWD on so many lists here. Such a fantastic and underrated pin IMO.

I don't think I'd ever be able to make an accurate list cuz I love em all. However my wife has clear favorites of the 17 in our gameroom. I know this because she spends an hour down there every freaking day after work!!! Took me 10 years to reprogram her but her codes finally complete. The sound coming from the basement tells me her favorites at the moment are....
1. St pro
2 imdn pro
3 spiderman ve
4. GB pro
5. Woz

She just got up for work and she's singing iron maiden, says she can't stop even though she's never listened to them before we got the pin.

Life is good....

Ps. Honorable mention...
My 7 yr old daughters favorite for last couple years.
1. Judge dredd

Top down:
TWD premium
IMDN premium
STTNG
AFMR LE