Tarps are a pain in the ass for wrapping an individual game!!!
I can shrink wrap a game in about 1-2 minutes VS fighting with a tarp and bungee cords. Plastic wrap fits the shape of any game I have to move. A plastic bag won’t fit every game and tarps...well we have all had our own experience...mine is usually I need a bigger tarp or multiple tarps and are a pain to get secure with bungees.
Don’t over think this....bags wear and tear, get holes and leak after a couple uses. And it’s going to rip and tear when you slide/drag the game out most likely unless you have the game on dowels and are able to roll it out.
Get a roll of plastic wrap and a couple of ratchet straps and you are good to go.