I have an opportunity to purchase one of these two this weekend. I have played both titles on location. I really like both. I do not have room for both

My concern is how long they hold their interest, particularly TNA. My current lineup is fairly diverse, so I think either would fit in. I have only played both on location, so curious what the perspective is from owners. Thanks for any additional insight!

Curious why that is?

You are a rules breaker

Yep that is my concern. Neither are complex or deep games, but HSII seem a little more varied.

Why did you want to let it go and after how long of owning it?

Thanks for the opinions so far. Keep them coming!

A lot of helpful opinions here. I am a little surprised by the HS vs. the HS2 comments. I have always viewed the second as everything great about the first with some nice additions. I haven't owned my HS for very long, but I probably wouldn't have picked it up if I had not been looking for HS2. I do like the supercharger gimmick even as a break in the action. For me it ratchets up the excitement. If the STTNG music hasn't gotten on my nerves yet, I doubt ZZ top will.

Speaking of music, the TNA music and integration in the game is one my favorite aspects. So that isn't a detractor as another poster mentioned. I do understand multi-player is really where TNA stands out. If I pick it up, my son and I will probably play head to head the first couple of weeks solid.

What is on my mind now is which one will be easier to find again locally.

I appreciate all of the opinions. I ultimately went with TNA. The seller even offered a healthy discount on both and I was having bad thoughts of how I could make that work. The decision was helped along by another buyer coming in at the last minute and making a better offer on HS2. I was leaning TNA anyway, but damn the HS2 was in nice condition.