I think the majority of you guys are looking at a regular scenario, wherein anybody sells one of their current titles for "x" amount, where "x" = any amount higher than current market price.
In that case, I say" Have at er!" Market will dictate how much you get. If you profit, good on ya. Odds are if you sell it too low, someone else may flip it for more money anyway.
In this example however (Iron Maiden NIB LE), dirtbags are jumping on limited edition versions of a pin with the sole intention of screwing someone else over by marking it up.
Most manufacturers are ok supporting resold games, but now you're also potentially jacking someone's warranty. Someone who GENUINELY wanted to buy this title, but you managed to contact the distributor first.

Once again, this practice is perfectly legal so nobody will get in trouble -but then jumping on to a forum and defending your greedy practice, INSULTING the very people who love the hobby (some of whom very likely missed out on owning an LE), is further evidence of a severe lack of class.

And the excuse of: "well it's a collectible toy so it's ok" is garbage when you're explaining that on a forum of people who love collectible toys!

Maybe he doesn’t like hearing about people in this hobby who screw over other people in this hobby.

Anyone who wanted to buy an LE but missed out, who then see what you’re doing is going to feel screwed over.
And the 1 person you ripped off for one $2000 (or whatever it was that you added for your “services”) should also feel ripped off. Lastly, that same buyer if he/she ever has any warranty issues since they’re not the original buyer.

You continue to be as thick as possible, addressing only the piece that works in your favour.
The buyer obviously is “content” with the purchase and possibly even more so since they have acquired a hard to get LE.
But EVEN WITHOUT INTERVIEWING THEM, I can tell you with absolute certainty: THEY WOULD HAVE PREFERRED TO BUY DIRECTLY FROM THE DISTRIBUTOR.
a) for the price savings
b) for the added certainty of warranty coverage in the event something goes wrong

You offer NOTHING for this “service” and make thousands more. If you can’t see how has a negative impact on the hobby, I give up. Keep screwing over your fellow pinball enthusiasts. Have at er!