The reality is most Johnnys have hand issues.
I haven't seen a basically functional one sell under $1700 in a couple years. I also haven't seen one sell over $2400 in that time frame (except maybe one pristine example)
Faded, with hand issues and other minor issues - $1700. Faded, but functional - $2000. Not faded, fully functional - $2300.
Another point of reference - I'm picking up a fully functional one with minimal fade but a ramp that needs to be replaced for around $2100 next month.