The pinside archives estimate the value at 1900. Could fluctuate up or down depending on condition. $3500 seems a bit steep. I wouldn't call it a rare game.

haha 3500 is your ebay price for sure. It's actually a fun game, but I wouldn't spend 1900 on it unless I was loaded.

These actually shot up in value after the world series. A few sold on ebay but pricing was kind of all over the board($3k-5k). Several were relisted after being sold though. Is it worth that kind of price? Probably not. Like everything else, depends on how much someone is willing to spend.

Forgot to mention, the machine in the first post has some insert wear and wear around the pop bumpers. My brother has one and has thought about selling. Ive been trying to keep an eye out but they dont seem to get listed very often.