Since you asked I personally dont think either of those colors would look good. Especially after seeing a similar orange coating on that Fish Tales thats for sale on Pinside. But Im not really a fan of candy powder coatings on games in general.
I think getting the pieces chromed would look good and give it some “pop” without risking the game coming out looking tacky. But its your game so you should make it look the way you want it to look, everyone has different tastes.