EAPTM is my favorite, mainly because I have one. But even if I didn't I can see EATPM appreciating a lot more the POTO. WW a strong second.

Poto has the deepest rules if the games mentioned. WW is great but gets boring fast in a small collection. Eatpm is fun, good ramp shots but again, gets boring in a small collection.

POTO is based after the book.. not the broadway version.

I have a 1 pin collection and it is EATPM. I think all pins might get a bit stale in a very small collection but I still enjoy playing it more than the JP and X-files that I had in my 2 pin collection. Plus I have had it for 3 months and haven't even considered selling it... which is a long time for me.

Elvira is better, Although most people will probably say whirlwind.

I have had WW for about 2 month and already want to sell it. It gets boring fairly fast and the fan wears on you after awhile...

EAPTM would be my choice. POTO had , glad it's gone. WW was once Shantastics , it was a great example , fun as well, it became part of a trade.