Potc is worth mor but RBION is a much better game

POTC worth more but yes RBION is the better game.
POTC is diff'rent i'll give it that but i can see it getting super repetitive at home.

RBION worth less but more fun

POTC is a more valuable game but RBION is a better game.

I like both, but I like POTC more. Like everyone else already pointed out, RBION is probably the better pin, and available for less money. They’re both fun unique pins. Also to be truly imamaculate, the pin would have to be legless.

I own both but cannot tell you which is better. I've owned RBION since it came out and POTC for 3 months. Owning RBION this long says something, but also means I kind of take it for granted. Some random musings below.

RBION has great playfield, ramps, vari-target, idol magnet, but doesn't really have a mechanical toy. The talking head is just a head that lights up.

POTC has 3 mechanical toys! The mix-master (tortuga), the ship (of course!) and the chest.

Both are great looking games, IMHO.

POTC can seem very open on the bottom 1/3 of playfield, but it works well for the game.

RBION can have short ball times, by default.
POTC can have long ball times, by default (I opened up my outlines to make it harder!)

RBION is a Whitestar game
POTC is a SAM game

Which is better? That's for you to decide. Or get both

I don't have much about these games on my site because they have been very reliable (and I mostly document repairs). But here's two links

https://www.aaarpinball.com/POTC/POTC.htm
https://www.aaarpinball.com/RBION/rbion.htm

... Altan

Ripley's all day! POTC is fun but it isn't half the game that Ripley's is. The choice is clear unless you are a diehard POTC fan.

ive heard that the ship mech is kind of a pain in the butt if it breaks the way they designed it fwiw