Sounds like a very fair price with all those options, you could remove the expensive options and sell a la cart but overall I think you hit a good price with all these options.

PotC is built like a tank compared to the Stern pros you see today that sell for $4700 new with no PF support, no lollypop style side rails etc..

Edit don't like that gouge in the head that's really what's bringing the price down, people like me like mint or 98% games games and that gouge is an eyesore. I'm sure that's knocking hundreds off the price.

I mean I'd rather get a 98% game no wear with less mods for similar price. My HUO PotC looks as new and I've seen a few others as good. If there was some way to repair that scratch I'd bet it would sell better.

Also do you have a shooter lane picture?

I am not sure where it should be priced based upon the options you have. The ColorDMD really looks great.

My neighbor picked up a perfect, bone stock, HUO (less than 250 plays) in NJ for $4,600 around 6 months ago.

You could probably sell all the mods for $700-800 but I know that's a bitch selling 10 different pieces.

Actually I think it's a fair price (but with negotiations) you might be prepared to accept less. I mean usually I'd price a game and be willing to accept 5% less if the deal was clean.

I'd bet the head gouge would be ok painted if done by a good repairer but likely something I'd let the next owner worry about, don't want to spend money and still have the buyer with something to complain about if the paint is not exactly perfect.

Where are you trying to sell this for $5k? Put it up on Pinside and see how it goes.

You can put it in the market but have it not placed in he forum. I don't think people will bash you for pricing it correctly and having too many photos.

If u were closer id be makeing u a offer very close to your asking price.... the gouges suck but the nice mods more than make up for it . Glws

Need to pull my ads but I have a trade in place on mine. I valued it at 4500. It was routed, but low plays after a shop in january. I had 5-6 solid offers and no one blinked at my price. Aside from new parts (sails, clutch, flipper rebuilds, compass decal) it has leds.

The real question is if someone is going to place a premium on yours for being a test machine and if they will want some of the mods you have. I think 5k is more than fair though, just going to take the right buyer.

It'll sell here I'd bet. Location is key, if a guy in MD wants it but you're in MI then it's not going to matter much, but a local sale is best for both parties cheaper less trust etc..

I like those sling shot plastics btw where did you get them?

Is this a gouge going right into the wood of the cabinet or a mark making a line on the paint? Gouge to me goes right into the wood also. So use gouge only if it is a gouge. Show the mark by the front door also with a pic. Shooter lane pic too. Why not? Pics look better with game on than off also. I like POTC a lot. Picked up a LOTR over it recently, but it was really close.
GLWTS!

I think you have it priced right. If you have trouble selling it, pull the colordmd ( use it in something else or sell it), then sell potc for $4600. Doubt you'll have any trouble selling at $4600.

I sold a documented single owner prestine HUO with less than 250 plays and cointaker premium LEDs for 5000. Tough game to sell. The killer is the cab . People who are willing to pay top dollar what perfect....... I would say 4400/4600 unless you want to sit on it for a while.