I own both, I have had Demolition Man for 16 years and never tire of it, tuned up it's a wonderful pin, add Led's and color DMD with the swear rom's and BOOM! Through mirror blades and a terrific Williams Widebody. Top 35 pin. DemoMan suffered from ill repair and people got a bad opinion. I notice that pinheads that list their games seem to always have a DemoMan in the collection and really like it.
Fish Tales does not come close to The Shadow which also suffered the same fate as DM. Divertors didn't work, rings didn't light, flippers sucked, ramps where broken, who can like a pin like that. BUT, a fully working Shadow is so much fun, and a beast to play, one of the most challenging pins ever.
Have both and I give a slight edge to Demolition Man
IMG_0571 (resized).JPGIMG_0781~photo (resized).JPG