There are two camps, but I agree with this. My MBr PF looks like a minefield after less than 1500 plays and those dimples will turn into flaked paint and all of this digital printing you see elsewhere is exploding on contact after a few plays. Let's see what they look like after a year or two. It's why I stopped buying CPR pfs.
Quoted from zr11990:You can remake all of them and they will not be as good as the originals. Let’s see if those playfields and electronics last as long as the originals. Not.
As I noted before, we all have different expectations, needs, wants out of a machine. My MBr was my first "new" machine. I haven't played a ton of the newer games and those I have (Stern), I have not liked because they feel cheap to me. There was a lot of hype surrounding CGC, so I went with them versus another original. I felt let down b/c the quality of the wood and metals is sub par.
I had no idea there was a 90 year old grandpa residing in this middle aged woman's body screaming bout the good o'l days where dimples were few and far and ink adhered to the playfields and to get off my lawn, but here we are. While I cling to times of pinball past I think this post nails it, we simply do not have the quality of raw goods they did then, and if Williams was still in business this is what they would be putting out.
Anyhoo, it actually change my point of view a good bit. I have no idea what CGC is going to put out next, but I do look forward to it. I know what to expect now and how to address the issues at hand (buy and clear a spare pf). BBBr and possible TOMr would be buys for me. It's clear they are taking their time to put out quality versus quantity.
Quoted from dts:I love all of the remakes, but frankly preferred my original MMs and AFM over them. I've owned all of the remakes. MBr does seem like an improvement over the original imo, but that will be argued forever. They are all great. CGC is just using the same tools of Williams, same silkscreened playfields, same company, Churchill, building cabinets, with the implementation of newer technology. This is basically what Williams would have done if they were still around.