Quoted from Squeakman:Mike, can you elaborate on the zinc plating? Most restore threads I have seen just tumble those parts and put them back on the machine. Is there any harm of corrosion or whatever if they are not powdered or zinced?
The majority of the metal parts in a pinball machine are fabricated out of steel, which is a metal alloy composed primarily of iron. In simple terms, oxidation (or corrosion) occurs when oxygen combines with metal at an atomic level. For example, rust (iron oxide) is formed by the redox reaction of iron and oxygen in the presence of water or air moisture.
Chemistry lesson over
To prevent oxidation a protective barrier must be applied to the surface of metal alloys containing iron. This is why the steel parts in pinball machines where originally zinc plated. In areas where the plating is compromised you’ll often see oxidation occurring, usually small white spots. Overtime, if left untreated, these white spots can turn into red rust spots. When you add water (spilt beer or soda pop), the oxidation process is accelerated. This is why coin doors and lockbar receivers on machines from this era are almost always covered in rust.
You can tumble your metal parts using a polishing media; the most popular approach seems to be walnut shell with Flitz. Tumbling will clean and removed mild levels of corrosion (the white spots). The Flitz polish will actually leave a thin film/residue on the surface of your metal parts. However, once this film wears off (which often can occur while handling the parts during reassembly – the oils in your skin will wreak havoc on exposed metal surfaces as well), your metal parts will again be exposed to oxygen and the process of oxidation will occur.
The only way to really eliminate oxidation is to prevent oxygen from interacting with the metal. You have several options: (1) plating, (2) painting, (3) powder coating, or (4) applying a wax/polish to the surface of your parts. Option #4 is the easiest in terms of labor and cost, but it’s also the least effective approach.
I’ve tried carnauba wax, Mothers Mag, Flitz, etc. and I find Mothers to be the most effective polishing treatment for minimizing oxidation. I’ve also buffed and clear coated parts, which looks very nice. I’ve also re-plated parts, which is probably the preferred “purist” approach. It’s all a matter of what you’re trying to accomplish. For this machine I chose to powder the parts because I wanted to customize the look of my machine. The cost to powder vs. plating is comparable, so it’s a matter of preference.
Hope this answers your question.