Quoted from robin:What about copyrights? Are they a factor if you share models that you model yourself?
I am NOT a lawyer, so please take with a grain of salt: Artwork is copyrightable, and should not be included. However, parts are not copyrightable. This is why you can buy replacement car parts from sources other than the OEM.
Quoted from robin:And what kind of file formats are we talking about? I imagine a playfield protector is a different format (2d) vs a 3D printed popbumper cap?
Yeah, the formats would be based on the tool used by the Maker. As my work is 2D, I used a decade old copy of Adobe Illustrator (CS5), and at the moment my work is in .ai format. However, within Illustrator, I can save or export my work to several other formats such as .svg and .dwg.
I would recommend establishing preferred formats, but using it as a guideline rather than a rule.
Quoted from Isochronic_Frost:It will probably require moderating, or some sort of review process for files uploaded if Pinside hypothetically allowed it.
I agree moderation is required to ensure files are pinball related, don't violate copyright, and were created by the up-loader.
.
One more thing: Licensing. I think that you can make a rule, where if you upload your creation, you automatically grant permission for anyone to use the work for personal use. However, the Maker should have the ability to specify a license for Commercial use. Ex:
1) No Commercial Use Allowed.
2) Contact Maker For Permission to use Commercially. (Maker may request royalties. That is between the Maker and the Manufacturer, Pinside is not involved.)
3) Commercial Use Allowed, Maker Must be Credited.
4) Commercial Use Is Unrestricted.
- Mark