hmmm, I’ll guess you’ll get either many or few responses - theme matters, it has to be fun, pinside ranking is worthless, new games have much deeper rules and older games are too shallow, newer games have no humor and no magic, build quality, repairability....
or we can talk about Hendrix - nobody playing guitar for two years can touch him - but most of the folks in the pinball industry today have been doing it for much longer than two years.