I usually look at three lists when looking at a pin's rating - Pinside Top 100, Caucasian2Step's ratings from Pinside, and the International Pinball Database (IPDB) For example:
Caucasian2Step #1 - Twilight Zone
Pinside #4 - Twilight Zone
IPDB #1 - Twilight Zone
This does tend to downplay new pin fever somewhat from the Pinside Top 100 list.