So there are games you love and yet hate the theme. It seems more often than not my favorite pins are themes I don't like. My list is as follows:
Iron Maiden. I hate the band. But the pin is incredible.
Dialed In. I cant say I hate the theme, but it's not great. And yet the game is amazing.
Shadow. Theme is meh, game is mind blowing.
Road Show. Stupid premise, super fun shots and toys.
Now that I think about it, more times than not, the themes I enjoy tend to be games I really dont like. Southpark, Game of Thrones, Ghost Busters, Deadpool, any Star Wars ever, etc.
I guess my point is, I couldn't care less about theme as long as the game is good. Shame they don't match up most the time for me. :/