Sorry to create the first Schism in such young and promising Thread....but.
I'm Team Gilmour all the way.
Roger does not play well with others..... famously so.
Unfortunately I think Waters would think Pinball is unworthy of his artistic vision.
It might be possible in only Floyd music from Momentary Lapse of Reason onward, and Live versions of older songs from 1987-1994 tours were used.
Gilmour Mason could probably do this without Waters permission.
Waters would just get royalties.,... and constantly Mock it forever.