Quoted from pinlawyer:I got fucked by a 2-player game where Player 1 mistakenly started a one-player game. He drained Ball 1 and walked away. I plunged and began to play, only to notice that I was playing HIS Ball 2. I got fucked by a stupid rule or bad call, not sure which. Had to take a 0.
Similar thing happened two years ago at Pinburgh. A player started only a one player game. We noticed it after he drained and called for a ruling and the rule (from Bowen) was that the player plays through and then the other players play a 3-player game. I wasn't happy about it at the time but the rules are the rules.
Your particular situation is especially sucky because you played out of turn only because of someone else's screw-up.
There's a player in my area who I could totally see deliberately abuse this situation, both to get a game by himself and also in the hopes an unsuspecting player would step up and auto-DQ himself.
When I ran PPE 2011, I printed the rules out on 11x17 paper and pinned them up outside the tournament room because I knew these kinds of 'iffy' situations could happen. Several times during the tournament I had the free 'out' of saying, "the rules are posted right outside the door - you should have known better."