Lastly, you guys should get to know pinball pricing resources such as:
http://bostonpinball.biz/ebay0513.htm
This site keeps track of selling prices for pinballs on...eBay!!! Below you will see an accurate lsiting of what the eBay prices YOU reffered to earlier in your post actually are. You are WAY off on many of your prices. Keep in mind too that condition matters and many of the eBay listings were likely for much nicer, non routed machines. I would strongly urge you to price more in line with what these machines are selling for. You are retail and they may be a bit higher, but not nearly the extent to which you have taken these prices. See the comparison below:
FAMILY AMUSEMENT --------------------- BOSTON PINBALL (eBay)
Pirates of the Caribbean $4799 ------------------- $5662
STERN spiderman $6699 -------------------------- $9500 but, that was almost definitely BLACK SM, not the same machine here, overall average was $4097
Jack Bot $2299 ------------------------------------- $2062
EARTHSHAKER $1999 ----------------------------- $____ no year to date sales, overall average is $1205 which is low in my opinion. $1999 at a retail price wouldn't be absurd.
No Fear $2499 -------------------------------------- $2223
Addams Family (very nice) $7999 (HUO) -------- $5518
Monopoly $2999 ------------------------------------ $____ no year to date sales, overall average is $2543
INDIAN JONES (WMS wide body) $5499 (HUO) -- $5553
PLAYBOY (Stern) $3499 ---------------------------- $2250
SOPRANOS $4299 ---------------------------------- $3644
South Park $1899 ---------------------------------- $____ no year to date, overall average is $2200
Lord of the Rings $4799 --------------------------- $5028
World Poker Tour $2799 -------------------------- $2310
Terminator 2 $2699 ------------------------------- $1534
Space Shuttle $1599 ------------------------------ $____ no year to date sales, overall average was $230
SlugFest $1899 ------------------------------------ $1776
Wheel of Fortune $6599 -------------------------- $____ no year to date sales, overall average was $3387
Hurricane $2400 ---------------------------------- $1364
The Simpsons Pinball Party $4999 -------------- $4204
COMET $1500 ------------------------------------- $800 more or less...
Elvira PARTY MONSTER $4599 (HUO) ----------- $2395
Stern Batman PINBALL $6199 ------------------- $____ no year to date sale, aveerage is $4014