One theme that I am not shocked that it was never made, but would still be interesting to me would be MacGYVER. Anything could be used and incorporated into the game. Any location in the world would fit the theme. You could hit certain shots and collect different items to complete modes. There could be timed modes to escape a sinking boat, car being crushed in a junkyard, a locked walk in cooler, etc. There could be a magna save that looked like a roll of duct tape. I don't know how a swiss army knife could be included, but even if it was on a lever switch to launch the ball it would be kind of cool.

The Wolfman. The Benicio Del Toro movie. Or a serious Universal Monsters game in black and White. The movie Sucker Punch.

They should make a Here Comes Honey Boo Boo machine, that way there would be at least one game that I would not want to own seeing as how I want all the others.