Finally got around to watching this show. Just fantastic writing and lots of great storylines. While I would love to see new non-licensed titles, I think this could make a great pinball theme. There could be some great callouts. Heck, perhaps I'll just build one of my own.
I can imagine several great modes: The Final Five, Gaeta's mutiny, New Caprica Rebellion, One-eyed-Tigh, the list could go on and on.