Quoted from Pinball-is-great:

Here's a possible selection of pins to consider for your awesome pinball club:
(1) WOZ from JJP, set up in a separate spot in your new place.
Some new Sterns from 2010/2011/2012
(1) AC/DC premium 2012 Stern, (1) Transformers LE 2011 Stern,
(1) Tron: legacy LE 2011 Stern, (1) Iron Man, 2010 Stern.
The (4) good ones from the 00's decade:
Batman TDK (Stern 2008), Spider-Man (Stern 2007), LOTR & TSPP (Stern 2003)
The above totals (9) so far.
Get (9) awesome pinball machines from the 90's decade:
(1) should be RFM or SWE1
Must have the top rated pins, so (1) MM, (1) TZ, (1) AFM, (1) MB
Better get these also: (1) ST:TNG {Williams '93 widebody}, (1) GNR {Data East '94 widebody}
May want to get top one from Alvin G & Co --> (1) Mystery Castle 1993
And a top one from Capcom such as (1) 1995 Pinball Magic [note: BBB is a bit pricey]
Then (3) from the 80's that have good gameplay and great artwork:
{1 early 80's, 1 mid 80's, 1 late 80's, many to choose from, so have fun deciding}
For the final (3) of (24) total, it would be cool to have:
(1) 50's Gottlieb woodrail type that has nice artwork and is in excellent condition.
(1) mid/late 60's Gottlieb w/ the now conventional design of 2 flippers at bottom, and in-lanes that return ball to flippers, w/ mechanical and/or lighted backbox animation, and great artwork.
(1) mid/late 70's Gottlieb (e-m or ss) that's fun to play & has great artwork {example: Joker Poker}.
I bet that line-up would bring people in to Skill Shots to play some pinball. Good luck!