Quoted from delt31:Narrowed down to 4 now:
IJ
WOZ
TSPP (assuming Homer's doh can be turned off)
Metallica
Interested in peoples rankings.
WOZ is awesome, but it doesn't really have traditional modes where you advance through a scene...The Hobbit has them in spades though I guess it isn't on your list. The WOZ modes are more points based versus objective based. Most of the modes are timed versus having an "end" to them. I wouldn't say MET is really mode based either. It has some, but they're a minor part of that game.
So that leaves IJ and TSPP. IJ is a clunky, slow turd IMO. TSPP has that early Stern clunky feel to it, but the rules are fantastic. TSPP for the win.